I’m having some mixed feelings about whether or not its time to wean Elena from the pacifier, and maybe writing those feelings down will help me decide. She’s 15 months now, the age that Halle was when I weaned her, which worked perfectly for Halle. But as we all know by now, each kid is different and has different needs.
When I think about the reasons I weaned Halle at 15 months, those are:
1. I read somewhere that pacifiers or thumb sucking could start to have adverse effects on the kid’s teeth after about 18 months. Not even sure where I read that but that seems unlikely to me right now. I just did some quick research and this statement seems much more reasonable: “During a child’s first few years, sucking habits are unlikely to cause significant damage to a child’s mouth. But persistent and long-term sucking, especially after the permanent teeth begin to come into the mouth around age 6, can cause…” (and then it goes on to list the negative effects on the teeth and jaw). Anyway, I wanted Halle to be paci-free before the 18 months and just jumped the gun at 15 and it worked so I never looked back.
2. I wanted to wean her before she really got too attached and could communicate her disappointment about not having the pacifier. Although this is still somewhat of a concern, I already understand when Elena wants her pacifier and is disappointed because she doesn’t have it. Just because she’s not screaming the word “paci” doesn’t really change that. And I also understand now how flexible kids are and that no matter when I pull the plug she’ll have a few days of adjustment and then it’ll be over. So I’m not as worried about it.
3. Before I had Halle, I was aware of people’s judgmental attitudes about parents who let their older toddlers use a pacifier (many of them not even parents themselves), and I felt like I didn’t want to be one of those parents. This is a total nonissue to me now, as I have grown to appreciate my sanity far more than other people’s (often uninformed) judgments.
4. Halle was really ready and didn’t need it anymore.
Now that Elena is at this age, I keep telling myself that she’s just not ready. Far more than Halle did, Elena still puts everything in her mouth. I wonder if that’s because she’s used to having the paci and it’s one of those catch-22 cycles. Or if it’s just her nature right now to put things in her mouth. She’s 15 months old. They tend to do that, paci or not. And 99 times out of 100 I’d rather her have her paci in her mouth than whatever else she’s considering. And (shame on me for admitting it) I don’t have my eyes on her every minute of every day to stop her from putting things in her mouth. So there’s that.
She also has a real attachment to it. It’s like her blanky or her lovey. She doesn’t have an attachment to anything else. I’ve tried to get her interested in soft toys to sleep with, but they don’t interest her at all. And she absolutely loathes blankets. She runs hot, especially at night, and a blanket in Florida, at least in the summer, is totally out of the question. So it’s her thing that brings her comfort and I’m not sure I want to take that from her. But would she turn to something else in the absence of her pacifier and be fine with that other thing?
She’s surprisingly not that attached to it when sleeping. If she falls asleep without a pacifier, I don’t put one in her crib. She never wakes in the middle of the night wanting her paci in her mouth. She really doesn’t seem to associate it with sleep as much as most kids. Halle did wake up in the middle of the night (albeit rarely) only to want her pacifier replaced. Elena doesn’t do this. On the very rare occasions that Elena wakes up, putting the pacifier back in her mouth doesn’t put her back to sleep. This would be a reason in favor of just losing the pacifier, except that’s not what she uses it for.
The one thing I am concerned about is losing the pacifier before the baby comes. That’s only 4 or 5 months away (UM.. WHAT?!!). I’m a bit worried that having another baby with a pacifier is going to be confusing for Elena and make weaning her when I think she is ready much harder. And its going to make spreading germs to the baby much easier, because I can’t imagine her not taking the baby’s paci and putting in her mouth before giving it back.
So, having written this, I guess it did help. Despite all my arguments in favor of letting her keep the pacifier a little longer, I think I’m ready to pull it. I think being weaned before the baby comes is a totally valid concern and I think Elena will adjust just fine to life without a pacifier. I could give her another month or two, but I’m motivated to try it now. So, here goes. :)